My contemporaries were more upset about the Nobel than I was not to be recognised. One of them labelled it the 'No-Bell' prize! But it was fine by me. There's no Nobel Prize in astronomy and I was really proud that it was my stars that had convinced the prize committee that there was good physics in astrophysics.
How has a failure, or apparent failure, set you up for later success? Do you have a favourite failure?
Question
What is an unusual habit or an absurd thing that you love?
Daily life
Question
In the last five years, what have you become better at saying no to?
Daily life
Question
If you could have a gigantic billboard anywhere, what would it say and why?
Time & hindsight
I tried for a Ph.D. scholarship to work with Cedric Mims, but was told to apply again later because he already had a "scholar" and would take only one student at a time. … The following week a job in the Department of Experimental Pathology at the Moredun was advertized in Nature. We sailed for Britain in early 1967, on a very slow and cheap ship.
Laureate-written autobiography for Les Prix Nobel, Nobel Prize Outreach, 1 December 1996 source ↗
Others on this question
View all 80 →
Jocelyn Bell Burnell
Radio astronomer; discoverer of pulsars
Recorded
Louise Walsh, University of Cambridge 'Journeys of Discovery' interview series, 1 January 2020
source ↗
Shinya Yamanaka
Stem cell biologist; Nobel laureate in Physiology or Medicine, 2012
Working at the hospital, I found that my surgical skills were not as good as I expected. One time it took me two hours to do a surgical operation which could have been completed in 30 minutes by other surgeons. My supervisors were very tough on new residents like me, and I lost confidence in my ability.
Recorded
Laureate-written autobiography for Les Prix Nobel, Nobel Prize Outreach, 1 December 2012
source ↗
Robert Ballard
American oceanographer who discovered the wreck of the RMS Titanic in 1985
People not believing me. It's getting a little easier, but it's funny how people will say, "I don't think you can do that." Then you do it, and they say "That was great" and you say, "Well, I've got this other idea." "Naw, I don't think you can do that." So you do it again. When I said I was going to find the Titanic , no one believed it. When I said I was going to find the Bismarck , everyone believed it, and then I failed in my first attempt to find the Bismarck . So people expect you to succeed, but they don't want to stick their own necks out, and so risk-taking can be very lonely at times. You know that classic saying, which is very true: "Failure is an orphan, but success has many fathers." I'll tell you, when I'm most at risk, I look around, and there are not a whole lot of people there. But as soon as I succeed, they say, "We were always there." And I say, "Yeah, but 500 miles behind me."
Recorded
Academy of Achievement interviewer, Academy of Achievement interview, San Diego, California, 1 May 1991
source ↗
Norman Borlaug
Plant pathologist and agronomist; Nobel Peace Prize, 1970
So we had to take this special exam and I flunked it. Erv Upton passed it, and I was scared. I figured if I failed it, I wouldn’t have any chance of getting in. So I failed it beautifully. ... And so it was the first year of this general college, which gave an Associate of Arts degree after two years, and that was expected to be a terminal course. It turned out it wasn’t.
Recorded
Academy of Achievement recorded interview, American Academy of Achievement, 12 May 2008
source ↗
More from Peter Doherty
View profile →The two things that I miss most when living out of Australia are the bush and the Pacific coast, especially fishing in the surf at night! My father had a workshop and I learned to be a carpenter, a skill that has resulted in the manufacture of some very substantial coffee tables and a fair amount of time working on houses.
Recorded
Laureate-written autobiography for Les Prix Nobel, Nobel Prize Outreach, 1 December 1996
source ↗
On returning to Brisbane, I realised fairly quickly that I am an experimentalist at heart. A career as a diagnostic virologist was not for me!
Recorded
Laureate-written autobiography for Les Prix Nobel, Nobel Prize Outreach, 1 December 1996
source ↗
I share Alfred Nobel's conviction that war is the greatest of all human disasters. Infectious disease runs a good second.
Recorded
Laureate-written autobiography for Les Prix Nobel, Nobel Prize Outreach, 1 December 1996
source ↗
More on failure & regret
- What has been your biggest disappointment? 372 answers
- Who most deserves an apology from you, and why? 209 answers
- If you could edit your past, what would you change? 207 answers
- What is the worst thing anyone has said to you? 125 answers
- Which moment embarrassed you most? 125 answers
- What is the hardest thing that has happened to you, and what did you carry out of it? 40 answers
Also answered this
Venkatraman Ramakrishnan, Elinor Ostrom, Michael Houghton, Francis Collins, Mario Molina, Shinya Yamanaka
Search the directory for somebody in particular.
Explore further
- All failure & regret questions
- Explore the archive — by field, age, era, and subject