I went to the opera practically every night. I went to something practically every night, just learning and seeing and absorbing, and what I noticed is that there were singers that were only sort of slightly older than I whose voices sounded as though they were many decades older than that, and didn’t sound pretty, and I needed to understand what was happening. I mean there were singers that were 28 or 30 years old or something, and I would speak to them afterwards to say, “Was your voice tired tonight? Tell me what’s happening,” because I didn’t understand it. Their voices should have sounded fresh and blooming and wonderful, but instead they sounded different, and it was because they were singing a different opera every night, and singing whatever was offered, and I didn’t understand and needed to understand — because no one was telling me these things — why they just didn’t say no. Why didn’t they just say, “Oh no, I don’t think I should.”
What is something everyone in your world agrees about that you think is wrong?
Question
Which book changed the way you think, and what did it change?
Taste & recommendation
Some people think that anti-Semitism didn’t really exist in Germany until 1933. I certainly don’t want to take anything away from Hitler’s guilt, but the anti-Semitism I grew up with predated Hitler. We were called names. We had stones thrown at us. And, yes, this created real sorrow. We defended ourselves as well as we could. Funny thing, the common name we were called was Isaac—the way Muslims are called Ali or Mohammed. They’d call out, Isaac, go back to Palestine, leave our home, go to your place. They threw stones at us and shouted, Go to Palestine. Then in Palestine we were told to leave Palestine—history juxtaposed can be very ironic.
Lawrence Joseph, Cafés in Greenwich Village, New York, The Paris Review, Issue 122, Spring 1992, 1992 source ↗
Others on this question
View all 80 →
Jessye Norman
Operatic soprano and recitalist
Naomi Osaka
Japanese professional tennis player
Perhaps we should give athletes the right to take a mental break from media scrutiny on a rare occasion without being subject to strict sanctions. In any other line of work, you would be forgiven for taking a personal day here and there, so long as it's not habitual.
Yves Bonnefoy
Poet, essayist and translator
I started reading poetry in primary school—Victor Hugo, the romantics, and the Parnassians—they were part of the curriculum. In my grandfather’s library there were some anthologies of nineteenth-century poetry. Alfred de Vigny impressed me most; indeed I won a competition by reciting Vigny’s “Moses” with an enthusiasm that touched the examiner. In fact this poem and “La Maison du Berger” are among the most beautiful poems in the French language, unfairly neglected today.
Nora Ephron
Journalist, essayist, screenwriter and film director
People think that when you write something it’s cathartic, and I had written a lot of personal articles at Esquire, and people always say, “Oh God, it must have been so great when you finally wrote about having small breasts.” No. You get through that, and then you write it. It is not the writing that is the catharsis.
More from Yehuda Amichai
View profile →Very much so. I went to synagogue regularly. My first education was interpreting the Bible. But I also grew up with German folk songs and stories, which became as much a part of my imagination as the Bible stories. My sense of history came from these stories—I was fascinated with what you might call fairy-tale-shaped history. But from the beginning I felt I belonged to a different people, which wasn’t any problem for me. I made the German landscape, which was very beautiful to me—flowing rivers, mountains, forests, lakes—into a biblical landscape. The valley of sunshine into which we went on school excursions in my imagination became the valley in which David and Goliath fought.
Recorded
Lawrence Joseph, Cafés in Greenwich Village, New York, The Paris Review, Issue 122, Spring 1992, 1992
source ↗
More on values & belief
- Which living person do you most admire, and why? 408 answers
- What is the trait you most deplore in others? 199 answers
- What are you unwilling to optimise? 33 answers
- What have you come to understand about what it means to be human? 16 answers
- What do you need to believe in order to get through the day? 12 answers
- What is the most overrated virtue? 10 answers
Also answered this
Ursula K. Le Guin, Wisława Szymborska, Twyla Tharp, John Banville, Adam Zagajewski, Nora Ephron
Search the directory for somebody in particular.
Explore further
- All values & belief questions
- Explore the archive — by field, age, era, and subject